Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 17°C
London
Saturday 5th July 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

WHY WE CAN'T SIMPLY THROW AID AT BURMA

Story Image


BURMA: The UN is adamant that “getting in there” without official permission is an act of war

Friday May 16,2008

By Frederick Forsyth

LAST WEEK, watching BBC1’s Question Time, I witnessed the plumptious Piers Morgan, jowls a-quiver, shouting: “Get in there.”

He was offering his advice as to how this country should forcibly bring aid to the suffering people of storm-devastated Burma.

In short, he was advising the West to invade the place, as have other commentators. Whether the foul Burmese junta will co-operate in the aiding of its own people or not, even if the cause is humanitarian and good, roaring in without Rangoon’s consent is still invasion. And it probably would not work.

If you want to mount an air bridge, as the West once saved West Berlin in 1948/49, you need three things. You need take-off points that are close to the disaster zone. Neighbouring Bangladesh and Thailand have made plain their airfields are available if, but only if, the Burmese junta grants assent to receive the relief planes. So far it has not.

And you need safe landing grounds. There are no landing grounds in the Irrawaddy Delta, one of the most remote regions in Asia. It is a tangled web of creeks in a sea of mangrove. And you need safe skies. The Burmese tyrants have an air force; not very good but jet fighters will blow a low, slow freighter out of the sky. Penetrating sovereign airspace against national veto is an act of belligerence.

ì
I would like to see is every rotten, cruel, corrupt general in that junta publicised worldwide and charged with mass murder by criminal negligence.
î


If you want to air-drop cargo, you need safe skies and manned drop-zones. Neither are available. If you want to go in by sea, you need a fleet of cargo ships which can discharge the aid into an even bigger fleet of landing craft. We have neither. If you send your planes in under fighter escort and the landing craft under armed escort then you really have declared war.

If you wish to bring the aid by land, but without permission, you have to drive in. But that means neighbours willing to assist and it means armoured car escorts. Another naked invasion. (We invaded Afghanistan via willing Pakistan and we invaded Iraq via helpful Kuwait.)

SEARCH COLUMNISTS for:

The only successful air bridge bringing in relief food to save starving children against the wishes of the governing military junta occurred during the Nigeria-Biafra war 40 years ago. The Biafran children were dying; Nigeria’s blockade even denied powdered baby milk.

Refusing to watch the children die and do nothing, a group called Joint Church Aid chartered some clapped-out piston-engined cargo planes and flew missions, technically illegal, from the islands of Fernando Po (a Spanish colony) and Sao Tomé (Portuguese) over the Niger Delta and into the Biafran enclave.

I recall we had to fly in the dead of night, the planes showing not a spark of light, because somewhere above the delta two Nigerian Mig 17s were hunting us. It was – how shall I put it? – quite interesting.

About half a million children were saved from death. But this would not work in Burma. For one thing, back then the departure islands gave their consent. For another we were landing on an airstrip controlled by the Biafrans. In Burma, the Burmese army obeys the dictatorship and controls the whole Burmese territory. Illegal relief flights, even if they got through, could not land.

The sad fact is that with the UN adamant that “getting in there” without official permission is an act of war, and the West not prepared (or in Britain’s case even able) to go that far, there is little we can do about the horrible Burmese junta.

What I would like to see is every rotten, cruel, corrupt general in that junta publicised worldwide and charged before the International Criminal Court with mass murder by criminal negligence.

Meanwhile, I hope Wing Commander Morgan can calm down, go away, study the theory and practice of hostile air drops and perhaps volunteer as loadmaster on the first plane to take on the Burmese Migs.


User Image

AID TO BURMA AND THE REST OF THEM

21.05.08, 6:16pm

What is the point of sending aid to any Dictatorship? Can somebody tell me just how much of our handouts actually arrivesat the point of devastation and is utilised by the needy?

I will not give money to help the poor people in these areas, as I know they will never get it. My money will end up in a Swiss bank account as a small donation to the huge, ever expanding pension fund for the Dictator.

Greed is BAD not good. These SOB's are bad and they are greedy. They want our aid to fund their life styles. Their peoples do not count, in fact they cannot count as they are denied a decent education. Think Burma, think Zimbabwe, think South Africa. Think the whole of Africa.The so-called leaders are all weened on corruption and sure as hell itself, they ain't gonna change it for the health of their own citizens. They are just collateral and are destined to be damaged.

• Posted by: TiffReport Comment

User Image

THE BURMA AID PROBLEM

21.05.08, 11:11am

This article was absolutely spot on, and to add to it would be to waffle. Congratulations.

• Posted by: bluenoteReport Comment

User Image

WHY WE CAN'T SIMPLY THROW AID AT BURMA

18.05.08, 9:32am

Freddie is right. There is no point in sending aid to Burma because the people who need it will never get. We must resign ourselves to the fact that perhaps hundreds of thousands of people are going to die needlessly.

• Posted by: JohnnyBReport Comment

User Image

NOT YET AS BAD

16.05.08, 2:04pm

Britain is not yet as bad as Burma, but that could soon change if we don't boot out evil New Labour at the next opportunity.

• Posted by: CamertonReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Blog Author

Frederick Forsyth

To see all of the stories by this author, click the button below for a complete list.

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year