|
Columnists
![]()
|
UK NEWSFAD DIETS: WHY THEY MAKE YOU FATMonday November 23,2009 By Jo WilleyBRITAIN’S obesity crisis is being made worse by fad diets which promise a quick fix but are often doomed to end in failure, a major health conference will hear today.
Doctors have criticised the extreme nature of so-called ‘super’ diet techniques, which people cannot adhere to and then end up seeking solace in unhealthy foods. Some of these extreme diets also cause people to eat too much of certain types of foods, causing them to still put on weight. The only way to tackle the fat problem, they say, is to go back to basics and the simple principles of eating a variety of good foods, not consuming too much, and exercising. Professor Chris Hawkey, president of The British Society of Gastroenterology, will warn in a key speech today that if Britons carry on gorging as we are, by 2050 nine in 10 adults will be overweight or obese. He will say: “The problem facing our society is not the content of our diet but it’s the quantity we are consuming and the consequential impact on obesity. “We need to do away with quirky diets and get people to realise what will keep them healthy in the long run.” Prof Hawkey believes our obsession with quick fix weight-loss plans like the Atkins and Stone Age diets mean that the nutritional values of a well-balanced diet are being lost. Even if a fad diet does lead to some initial weight loss, people are then coming off it and eating unhealthily again, he will say. People are putting on weight as the fad diet has not installed in them the principles of eating well and not piling too much on their plate.
He warns that if current eating trends continue we will have a dramatically shortened life expectancy, obesity will be the main cause of death and there will be a surge in obesity-caused liver disease. Fad plans, such as high-protein or high-carbohydrate diets, can actually be unhealthy, and rarely work as a long-term way of managing weight, he believes. Similarly, slimming aids that suppress the appetite or speed up metabolism may produce short-term results but the weight soon creeps back on. Despite this, almost £30billion is spent globally on the diet and slimming industry each year. Catherine Collins, a clinical dietician working in the NHS, backed Prof Hawkey’s argument. “The problem with these sort of diets is it’s extreme dieting which most people can’t continue,” she said. To lose weight and keep it off she advises simple techniques such as keeping a food diary, including fruit and vegetables at every meal and down-sizing treats such as chocolate to smaller portions. “If you want to lose weight, it’s a marathon, not a sprint,” she said. In his speech, Prof Hawkey will say: “What’s important is to recognise that despite the popularity of fad diets, we are losing a grip on the fight with obesity. “Our research shows that 62 per cent of the public think obesity will continue to increase for at least the next 10 years.” Prof Hawkey will present the alarming new research at Gastro 2009, the world’s largest gastroenterology conference in London featuring 12,000 scientists. The YouGov study, commissioned by the British Society of Gastroenterology, aims to establish the public’s attitude towards food and dieting. It found that nearly half of Britons (49 per cent) classify themselves as overweight. It also discovered one in 20 women would try the Atkins diet if trying to lose weight. Speaking to the Daily Express before the conference, Prof Hawkey said: “Despite an interest in lots of different types of diet, as a society we are getting fatter. “The problem is we have a lot of diets around and we have people starving themselves, then putting the weight back on and that is not the way to go. “Choosing a diet for a particular content isn’t going to stop people getting overweight. “The issue is obesity and we don’t know how to tackle it. “In the whole of human history, there has never been anything quite like this. “It is going to become the biggest cause of death and the biggest cause of liver disease, overtaking alcohol.”
|
|
|||||||||||||













QUEST
24.11.09, 11:19pm
Tommytcg, may I ask you to provide your full name so I can check in scientific journals if you have scientifically achieved anything important?
Otherwise just please stop writing this nonsenses from fitness/bodybuilding forums which are based on very profitable nutrition industry instead of actual biochemichal processes in our bodies.
Posted by: Continental Report Comment
I AM NOT SURE IF THIS POST IS ADDRESSED TO ME.....
23.11.09, 1:17pm
"SO MARGALD
23.11.09, 9:56am
which `the fad diet, calorie countng or low carbo`?
• Posted by: Tommytcg • Report Comment"
I hope it is not because I do not understand the question.
Posted by: marigold Report Comment
DIETS
23.11.09, 1:11pm
The Atkins Diet, is not a fad diet, it is a way of life. "Scientists" persistently seek to denigrate the subject. Why??
It is a low carbohydrate diet whereby the dieter can establish just how much carbo he/she can take each day without putting on weight.
It advocates the use of cream instead of milk and butter instead of margarine and no limit to the amount of meat and fish consumed. Fruit is questioned because of the amounts of sugar it contains and we all know that sugar is 99% carbohydrate, which turns into fat and is stored if not burned off as energy. Vegetables are introduced gradually to find the correct balance as many vegetables do contain some carbohydrate. Breakfast cereals and most modern soft drinks are all banned because of their ultra-high sugar content. Refined flour, bread, pasta and rice also is off the menu unless it fits in with the correct balance.
Dr Atkins was hounded by the American Drug Administration who, in turn, were constantly lobbied by big Pharma and the the Big Cereal manufacturers, et al. All those fat people are everlasting customers and produce ever increasing profits for them, of course. No wonder they wanted to bring down the Atkins Diet.
There was even a sickening innuendo made that his death was caused by his diet.
In fact, he died from a fall caused by slipping on the icy pavement outside of his offices. He smashed his skull, went into a come and never regained consciousness.
No doubt there were cheers in the corridors of the above profiteers but his philosophy runs on. He was a pioneer in the highlighting the dangers of sugar consumption and it is only recently that serious questions are now being asked about the dangerously high levels of obesity in the Western World. They should have taken heed of Robert Atkins 20 years ago then they would not be in such a mess now.
Posted by: tiff Report Comment
FAD DIETS: WHY THEY MAKE YOU FAT
23.11.09, 12:27pm
Why do the scientists misinform? Is it to keep people obese and sickly, and line Big Pharmas pockets? Or is it politics? That they cannot admit they got it all wrong in the first place. The science is out there for them, so they cannot plead ignorance.
• Posted by: Tommytcg •
Yes Tommytcg you got it one.
The drug companiies and the fast food industry feed off each other. The fact that the NHS has a cozy relationship with the drug companies is just a big fat co-incidence. Just pull the other one and hear the tinkly noise.
Posted by: ricardo Report Comment
YAWN!!!!
23.11.09, 11:25am
The simple solution is eat less pies, walk more miles: there were not fat people in Belsen.
If energy input exceeds energy output, the result is weight gain. If energy output exceeds energy input, the result is weight loss. To use a popular phrase: "It's not rocket science."
Have a fag if you are hungry, it's an appetite supressant. Lester Piggot used to keep his weight down by smoking Havanas to stop the hunger pangs. Pity he didn't pay more attention to his accountant!
Posted by: Codeblue Report Comment
SO MARGALD
23.11.09, 9:56am
which `the fad diet, calorie countng or low carbo`?
Posted by: Tommytcg Report Comment
To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...