Daily Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 5°C
London
Saturday 22nd November 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

UK NEWS

DIANA: IT WASN'T MURDER

Story Image


DIANA: Killed in the car crash

Tuesday April 1,2008

By Richard Palmer, Royal Correspondent

THE coroner overseeing the Princess Diana inquest has ordered the jury to rule out the possibility that she was murdered.

Yesterday, Lord Justice Scott Baker ruled there was “not a shred of evidence” to allow them to conclude Diana and her lover Dodi Fayed were assassinated by MI6 on Prince Philip’s orders.

The coroner, citing the need for evidence beyond reasonable doubt to uphold a verdict of unlawful killing, threw out the possibility the pair were killed in a crash orchestrated by the Duke of Edinburgh or anyone else.

He said: “There is no evidence that the Duke of Edinburgh ordered Diana’s execution and there is no evidence that the Secret Intelligence Service (MI6) or any other Government agency organised it.”

His decision dealt a severe blow to Dodi’s father Mohamed Al Fayed, who has fought for a decade to prove the pair were murdered by spies because Philip feared Diana was pregnant by Dodi, a Muslim, and about to get engaged.

The coroner said even Mr Al Fayed’s lawyers had dropped many of the conspiracy claims after hearing testimony from more than 250 witnesses. Instead, they now relied on the theory that Philip’s fury at Diana’s decision to date Dodi ­created a climate of hostility that ­persuaded rogue MI6 officers to launch a freelance operation to frighten the couple at the least, he said.

The coroner, directing the jury on five possible verdicts they can reach, said the six-month inquest has dispelled many myths about the deaths of Diana and Dodi.

He said: “The benefit of these last six months is that various propositions that were being asserted have been shown to be so demonstrably without foundation that they are no longer being pursued by Mohamed Al Fayed’s lawyers, even if he still carries the belief of their truth in his own mind. They are not being pursued because there is not a shred of evidence to support them.”

SEARCH UK NEWS for:


He told jurors Mr Al Fayed’s beliefs may be genuine but he added: “A belief expressed in legal proceedings which is unsupported by evidence is worthless.”

Diana, Dodi and their stand-in driver Henri Paul, the acting security manager at the Paris Ritz Hotel, died after their Mercedes hit a concrete pillar in the Alma underpass in Paris just after midnight on August 31, 1997.

There was laughter in court as the coroner made a reference to John Loughrey, a self-confessed Diana “superfan”, who has attended every day of the inquest.

He told the jury: “No one except you and I and, I think, the gentleman in the public gallery with Diana and Dodi painted on his forehead has sat through every word of evidence.

“No one is as well-equipped as you are to decide the facts of the case.”

Summing up the evidence, he dismissed claims by renegade former MI6 officer Richard Tomlinson that rogue MI6 agents may have murdered the couple, using a bright flashlight in a plan echoing one to assassinate Serbian leader Slobodan Milosovic in the early 1990s.

The coroner suggested Tomlinson was wrong and had fabricated his claims to embarrass his former MI6 bosses.

No flashlight was mentioned in the first drafts of his book, which had described the assassination plot as a drive-by ambush.

The coroner said there was a welter of evidence to suggest Diana was on the pill, had a period mid-August and was
anxious not to get pregnant.

“The only evidence that Diana was pregnant comes from the mouth of Mohamed Al Fayed,” he said, pointing out that the Harrods tycoon claimed the Princess told him she was expecting in a phone call an hour before her death.

“On the other hand, there is a great deal of evidence that she was not pregnant, although you may think it cannot be proved with absolute scientific certainty that she was not.” He added: “The issue fairly and squarely raises Mohamed Al Fayed’s credibility. Is he a man on whose word you can rely?”

The coroner suggested there was no evidence to support claims that Diana’s body was embalmed illegally to cover up her pregnancy. The embalming was done lawfully and Home Office pathologist Dr Robert Chapman, who carried out a post mortem on the Princess in London, said it would not have prevented him finding evidence of a foetus. He did not find anything, he said.

On claims that the couple were engaged and had bought a ring, he suggested there was conflicting evidence. He also said nothing had been found to support claims Prince Philip sent Diana threatening letters. He also dealt with the Princess’s fears, famously expressed in a note to her butler Paul Burrell and in a ­conversation with her lawyer Lord Mishcon, that she was in danger of  being killed on the orders of her royal in-laws.

He noted several of Diana’s confidants said she regularly expressed fears for her safety but they were never sure how seriously to take them. “You will have to decide whether Diana did truly fear for her life and, if she did, whether such fears were justified,” he said.

The coroner will continue summing up today. The jury is expected to retire to consider its verdict tomorrow.


User Image

HEAR ME TOO. I WOULDN'T PUT MUCH STORE IN THE DIANASPEAKS WEBSITE

01.04.08, 10:04pm

Diana speaking through a medium? This sort of thing goes on in the USA? It does, but not everyone subscribes to it.

The Inquest has been held. Everything has been said that could possibly be said, except the truth of course by Butler Burrell. Coroner Justice Baker has come to the definite conclusion that Diana was not murdered. Only those who defiantly insist that she was will give credence to the idea that Diana won't rest unti ...."

In my view, there was no need for a murder plot. All the detractors had to do was to wait and see. Diana was on a fast trip to disaster. Ironically, it was in a Mercedes, not buckled up, driven by a chauffeur who ignored the posted safety limits in the Alma Tunnel and ran all the red lights in the Place de la Concorde, the approach to the tunnel, and in the company of a man who was known in Los Angeles for having a habit of telling his drivers to "Step on it."

If Diana is not resting, is uneasy, it should surely be because of the total waste of a life in the final month of hers. She threw caution to the wind. In my honest opinion, she was out of sync with what she had always folllowed : discretion at least, and not the least fastening her seat belt whenever she was in a car. If you are hell bent on self-destruction you don't need a helping hand on the way. She was not murdered. Thank you Justice Baker.

• Posted by: RothaymereReport Comment

User Image

"ONLY A FOOL BELIEVES WHAT THEY READ"? DEPENDS ON WHAT THEY ARE READING

01.04.08, 9:45pm

"Call no man fool." In line with similar good advice: "Whenever you write, whatever you write, never make the mistake of assuming the audience is any less intelligent than you are. " (Rod Serling)

It's all about discrimination, being discerning, the assumptions you make, and the conclusions you come to. You alone are in command of that. However ...

"But what a fool believes he sees
No wise man has the power to reason away
(Doobie Brothers: What A Fool Believes)

• Posted by: RothaymereReport Comment

User Image

SEE YA, WILL NOT MISS YA

01.04.08, 6:51pm

well i think ill give de express forums a miss from now on.
it was obvious from the start to me, whats going on, with this paper, but i just had a bit of fun for a while.
only a fool believes what they read, its like april fools day everyday with this rag.

• Posted by: supernovaReport Comment

User Image

OH AND HEARME

01.04.08, 6:32pm

go back to your web site "Diana speaks" and ask how she feels about her most private and intimate life being made public. Wonder how her boys are feeling about that?

• Posted by: crowoodReport Comment

User Image

HOW NICE JONO

01.04.08, 6:30pm

you keep posting parts of newspaper clippings that try to show Diana as being shallow. Daddy owns harrods indeed. Do you really think that would have swayed her anymore than the carpets with pink pharohs heads on them.
And as for the poster that says that Diana's boys still think of her - well obviously, just because she's dead doesn't mean to say her family have forgotten all about her!!!

• Posted by: crowoodReport Comment

User Image

WHY?

01.04.08, 6:06pm

why do certain posters keep sending links to find out more, it s not needed, all one as to do is google, or ask jeeves.
then you find a lot of info, thats correct and up to date.

• Posted by: supernovaReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Bigger desks for UK’s fat children

SCHOOL desks and chairs now have to be made larger because children are getting ...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Police probe derby football 'abuse'

Police are to speak with Liverpool and Everton football clubs about Sunday's acr...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(1)

‘Stop building mosques in UK’

NO more mosques should be built in Britain, a member of the Church of England’s ...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(22)

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year