Daily Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 6°C
London
Saturday 22nd November 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

UK NEWS

SCHOOL CATCHMENT FAMILY 'SPIED ON'

Thursday April 10,2008

A council has admitted it spied on a family using laws passed to track criminals and terrorists to find out if they were lying about living in a school catchment area.

The couple and their three children were put under surveillance without their knowledge by Poole Borough Council in Dorset for more than two weeks using powers under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA).

The family only found out about the spying when a school admissions manager told them.

The authority said it used the legislation to watch the family at home and in their daily movements because it wanted to know if they lived in the catchment area for a school which their three-year-old daughter wanted to attend.

Human rights pressure group Liberty called the spying "disproportionate" and "intrusive".

James Welch, legal director for Liberty said: "It's one thing to use covert surveillance in operations investigating terrorism and other serious crimes, but it has come to a pretty pass when this kind of intrusive activity is used to police school catchment areas.

"This is a ridiculously disproportionate use of RIPA and will undermine public trust in necessary and lawful surveillance."

The anonymous mother told the Bournemouth Echo she was shown the surveillance record, listing her movements from February 13 to March 3, including school runs with her children and the routes they drove.

The angry family told the newspaper the surveillance team wrote down detailed notes such as "female and three children enter target vehicle and drive off" and "curtains open and all lights on in premises".

The RIPA legislation allows councils to carry out surveillance but only if it suspects criminal acts have taken place.


User Image

OUTRAGEOUS!

11.04.08, 1:26pm

Isn't what this Council has done is illegal?

At the very least it was intrusive and highly inappropriate to use legislation which permits them to track terrorists and criminals for this purpose. And to keep this family under such close surveillance for so long must have cost a fortune.

If it wasn't illegal, then it should have been!

• Posted by: CathyKReport Comment

User Image

AND ANOTHER THING...

11.04.08, 11:56am

The system is up against a parent's strong instinct and tenacity to desire the best possible education for their kids. That, is a very tough problem to overcome.

• Posted by: ZeigfreidReport Comment

User Image

DISHONEST PARENTS.

11.04.08, 11:53am

If you want your kid to go to a good school then get religion or pay privately.

Although I disagree with parents lying to get their kids into a good school, the question ought to be asked is why are there bad schools? Why are faith schools better in educating kids than sink comprehensives? We used to have selection in the old days and it worked. If your kid was a numb nuts, he went to a secondary and if he had brains, he was sent to a Grammar.

You only have to have one disruptive pupil in the class to completely undermine the rest of the class's education. Take the kid out, punish him and the parents and if necessary, put the kid in a special school and allow the silent majority to continue their education unhindered.

• Posted by: ZeigfreidReport Comment

User Image

SCHOOL CATCHMENT ??

11.04.08, 10:19am

In all fairness I personally know of two families who had perfectly good comprehensive schools on their doorstep less than half a mile away but wanted their children to go to this other particular school 7 miles away, one woman lied and lied saying she was moving into that area and even actively kept going looking at properties till the child was registered and was going to this school wasting everyone's time because she had no intentions of moving
from where she lived, the other was my son who wanted me to say that the child was living at my address which would have got me into serious trouble because I live in a pensioners bungalow, plus I hate lying what I am trying to say is the extremes parents will go to get the best they can for their offspring

• Posted by: ANNRReport Comment

User Image

POLICE STATE!

11.04.08, 8:44am

Let this be a lesson to the brigade which says - if you have nothing to hide, you should not be afraid.

We are now living in a police state which has been created by the loony crooks in the House of Conmen/Contempt ,who only know how to line their pockets!

These lunatics have given drastic powers to the local councils (imprisonment for council tax non-payers,etc.) and others which are now used regularly on the innocent citizens of this country.

How can Bush, Brown and Bliar preach democracy in Iraq and Afghanistan when they themselves run police states!!!

• Posted by: NalinReport Comment

User Image

ADANAC - YOU GOT THAT ONE RIGHT !!

11.04.08, 4:00am

They already want to give all government employees powers of fining people etc. Makes you laugh really - Housing "Officer" - Welfare "Officer" -- Benefits "Officer" --- and not one of them holding the Queens Commission!!

• Posted by: DRAGONFLYReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Hours limit 'may impact on doctors'

A limit to working hours could prevent junior doctors gaining all the skills nee...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(3)

Drugs worth £100m 'traded in jails'

A former drug treatment policy advisor claims that an estimated £100m worth...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(7)

Brady back at work after quiz in soccer probe

Birmingham City managing director Karren Brady returned to work yesterday after ...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year