Daily Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 5°C
London
Saturday 22nd November 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

UK NEWS

‘FRANKENSTEIN’ EMBRYO BILL BACKED BY MPS

Story Image


WARNING: Tory MP Edward Leigh

Tuesday May 20,2008

By Gabriel Milland Political Correspondent

MPs last night backed a new law which will let scientists create “Frankenstein-style” part-human, part-animal embryos.

A Tory backbencher’s amendment, which would have banned the practice, was defeated by 176 to 336 – giving the Government a majority of 160.


Another amendment which would have banned only certain types of hybrid was defeated by a much smaller majority of just 63.


Scientists hope that cells from the so-called “Frankenstein” embryos can be used to create brain, skin, heart and other tissue for treating diseases.


SEARCH UK NEWS for:

The Tories and Lib Dems have given their MPs a free vote on all parts of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill.


But Gordon Brown allowed Labour MPs and ministers a free vote on only four key issues for the Bill’s committee-stage reading in the Commons. His decision followed a fierce campaign led by the Catholic Church.


When the Bill returns for its third and final reading later in the summer, prominent Labour Catholics like Ruth Kelly will have to fall into line or face the sack. The Transport Secretary voted in favour of the outright hybrids ban and the compromise.


Apart from Ms Kelly, those who voted in favour of the ban and the compromise included Defence Secretary Des Browne, Welsh Secretary Paul Murphy and Europe Minister Jim Murphy.


Tory leader David Cameron voted against the full ban but abstained on the compromise, despite it being put forward by his frontbench.


Scientists will now be allowed to insert human DNA into animal eggs.


Smaller than a pinhead, the hybrid embryos will be allowed to grow for up to 14 days before being destroyed.


Scientists believe that stem cells harvested from these embryos could provide the key to the treatment of conditions such as Parkinson’s disease, cystic fibrosis or muscular dystrophy.


Research is currently being held up by the shortage of human eggs to create stem cells.


MPs were also due to vote on so-called “saviour siblings” – babies genetically engineered to provide material for ill family members.


Tory MP Edward Leigh, who gave the Frankenstein warning, said the Bill would allow for the creation of true hybrids – in which an animal egg is fertilised by a human sperm.


Opening the debate with an amendment prohibiting outright the creation of hybrid “admixed” embryos, Mr Leigh claimed there was “no evidence yet to substantiate” the claims that they could lead to cures.


But Labour MP and former biology lecturer Ian Gibson said: “Some people have done that, actually.


“It is kind of secret in some ways because there is commercial interest, but some drugs have been developed using embryos and the effects of them.”


Today debate will centre on making it easier for lesbians to have IVF babies, as well as the abortion limit.


Mr Brown will vote for the removal of a requirement for IVF clinics to consider a child’s “need for a father”, while Mr Cameron believes it should stay.


The Tory leader has also indicated that he would like to see a reduction in the current 24-week limit for abortion, while Mr Brown wants it to remain.


User Image

MENGELE WOULD HAVE APPROVED TOO

20.05.08, 12:08pm

Where does it all stop?
The Government and those in the medical field pursuing this type of reseach are a disgrace to decent and civilised humans.
The Government is especially hypocritical in that it doesn't care about the thousands of people who die yearly due to MRSA etc.
All those MPs who voted in favour should now be used as guinea pigs in medical research, let them be made use of.

• Posted by: The_BossReport Comment

User Image

‘FRANKENSTEIN’ EMBRYO BILL BACKED BY MPS

20.05.08, 10:02am

Frightening isnt it, and what next ? This Government have proved themselves totally and absolutely incapable of monitoring anything effectively.

Just look at the debacle over Immigration and Border Control just to name but one of a hundred issues - so how can we believe that these embryos will be effectively monitored and destroyed after 14 weeks ?

Once Scientists start playing God, Just imagine the Horror of some idiot creating another clone of Bliar or Prescott.

• Posted by: EmperorMingReport Comment

User Image

EMBRYO FARCE

20.05.08, 9:28am

Why do scientists want this so much? Follow the money and think of all that lovely funding!
I, for one will not be holding my breath waiting for the mass of 'new cures' promised, I'm still waiting for those from the last lot of millions of pounds spent by the gullible taxpayer and from the one before that and the one before that.....

• Posted by: BenEllis70Report Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Lifelong watch on teenage knife thug

A NOTORIOUS teenage thug was yesterday given a rare life order because of the th...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

MPs will not appeal expenses ruling

MPs have abandoned their legal battle to keep secret the details of their expens...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

1 in 5 primary school leavers fail the 3Rs

SCHOOL standards have fallen to a “totally unacceptable” level, experts warned y...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(3)

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year