Daily Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 5°C
London
Saturday 22nd November 2008 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

UK NEWS

SAVE TAXPAYERS' CASH? ASK THE WHITEHALL TEA LADIES SAYS LABOUR MP

Story Image


DENIS MACSHANE: Time to tackle the waste

Wednesday May 28,2008

By Gabriel Milland, Political Correspondent

A FORMER minister attacked high taxes and state waste yesterday saying “tea ladies in the Foreign Office” knew more than the expensive consultants employed by the Government.

Denis MacShane, the former Europe Minister, said only tax cuts had a remote chance of saving Labour at the next election.

But cutting waste should also have a high priority.

When he suggested that colleagues use budget airlines to cut travel costs, he claimed he was stared at like he had “left a nasty mess on their doorstep”.

Mr MacShane, who has a reputation for independent thinking, complained about the vast sums Whitehall spends on consultants – at least £2billion a year according to official estimates.

He said: “As Europe Minister I was baffled to be told I had to waste 90 minutes being quizzed by a consultant when the kindly but shrewd tea ladies in King Charles Street (the Foreign Office) knew what needed to be done.

“How much was paid to the consultant? What happened to his report? No one in Whitehall knows or cares.”

Mr MacShane’s astonishing attack came as anger continued to build inside Gordon Brown’s party over massive tax rises for ordinary motorists. But backbencher Brian Iddon, MP for Bolton South East, said voters’ fury was not just about motoring.

“I’m getting complaints from our core Labour vote that they feel that the Labour Government is just hitting them left, right and centre,” he told BBC Radio 4’s The World At One. “They are heavily bruised at the moment.”

SEARCH UK NEWS for:

Despite being part of a Government that has increased the overall public sector payroll by over 800,000 since 1997, Mr MacShane said tax cuts could be financed by cutting spending.

He said that he did not know of a single minister who privately “does not despair at the waste of money on pointless projects, publications, or legions of press officers that add no value”.

Mr MacShane said it was bizarre that UK aid to India totalled £1billion when that country has more billionaires and millionaires than the UK. In another swipe at waste, he complained: “Can I be the only MP outraged that town clerks – even dressed up with fancy titles such as chief executive – can now get paid £200,000-plus for running rubbish collection services in small towns?”

He noted David Cameron’s Tories have yet to commit to a radical bid to slim down Britain’s bloated public sector.
He said: “Labour should not be frightened of being a party that leaves more money in the pockets of hard-working individuals, starting with those at the lower end of the income scale.

“A Labour government that got serious about weaning its bureaucracy and clients off dependency on the citizen’s money would find itself popular again.” Mark Wallace, Campaign Director of the TaxPayers’ Alliance, said: “Denis MacShane is right to say the Government should spend less and tax less, though it’s a shame he didn’t insist on that policy when he was a minister.

“If someone like Denis MacShane is willing to argue for tax cuts it’s a sign of how ­radically times are changing.”
Another senior Labour figure also laid into the party’s sense of purposelessness yesterday.

Phil Collins – an ex-speechwriter to Tony Blair and who now works for possible leadership candidate James Purnell – said Labour had become addicted to big Government.

The party, he added, had a future that “looked bleak” and it really needed to become less authoritarian.


User Image

SMOKING BAN / FOOD PRICES

28.05.08, 6:25pm

Dr Iddon also cited the ban on smoking in public places and rising alcohol and food prices as particular causes of anger. I think he's spot on with all three there - people are sick of the government trying to control their lives.

• Posted by: JohnYorksReport Comment

User Image

I BET THE AVERAGE WHITEHALL TEA LADY HAS MORE CREDIBILITY THAN THE GAGGLE OF INCOMPETENTS IN POWER

28.05.08, 3:13pm

When you get a former Minister (Labour) attacking the "high taxes and state waste" of NuLabour it speaks volumes for the abject state of this banana republic.

Talking of banana republics - I am sorry to repeat myself - I have many dear friends living in banana republics in Africa. Those people are all HAPPY. They are all LAUGHING. They CARE for each other. The FAMILY is paramount. NOT a CCTV camera in sight.

People in the UK are NOT HAPPY. They are NOT LAUGHING. They do NOT CARE for each other (they just kill each other instead). The FAMILY in the UK is a dead duck.

Hence, we have feral yobs roaming the streets looking for their next victim.

The police could not care less. NOBODY could care less.

NOBODY IS LISTENING TO JOE PUBLIC.

• Posted by: ReubenMohawaliReport Comment

User Image

UNECESSARY CRITICISM

28.05.08, 2:30pm

There is completly unecessary criticism regarding CONSULTANTS - when you examine, look at, experience, meet or become aware of the types" who are labourite Ministers and MP''s** is it so obvious that they are incompetant, unintelligent, greedy, self centered, inexperienced and inefficient that there is no way that they can govern the Country well or sensibly or find or think of policies with out outside advice.

**To be really fair to labourites many of other political candidates & MP'S are similar "types"

The only way to get this Country back on its feet - what ever Party wins power is to ensure that MP's particularly Ministers are up to their job. This could only be done by making all candidates take tests, examinations and CRB checks arranged by independent people perhaps committee chaired by the Queen - call it a Parlimentary assessment centre!

• Posted by: nowyouknowReport Comment

User Image

THE WHITEHALL TEA LADIES

28.05.08, 2:28pm

That has a ring to it as a new Political Party. Yeah, we could have a party of real people who know how to manage everyday things in a simple and logic way. So I say kick out the MPs of all existing parties and lets install our own, "The White hall tea ladies party".

• Posted by: fireowlReport Comment

User Image

SAVE TAXPAYERS CASH. ASK THE TEA LADIES.

28.05.08, 12:35pm

All peeing in one anothers pockets, congratulating, shaking one anothers hand. Sickening to decent people, of course ask the tea ladies, window cleaners, gardeners tradesmen, whatever. Don't ask one of the gang it will cost you a fortune, and you will end up with aload of establishment dogma.

• Posted by: juan01Report Comment

User Image

SAVE TAXPAYERS' CASH? ASK THE WHITEHALL TEA LADIES SAYS LABOUR MP

28.05.08, 11:13am

Well these Tea Ladies actually LIVE IN THE REAL WORLD UNLIKE MANY OF THOSE TOTALLY INCOMPETENT SCROUNGERS IN WESTMINSTER.

• Posted by: EmperorMingReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Teenager charged with pub murder

A teenager has been charged with the murder of a 41-year-old man outside a pub. ...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Nuclear costs 'to rise by billions'

The cost of cleaning up Britain's ageing nuclear power sites is likely to rise b...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

PM urges oil supplies boost

Prime Minister Gordon Brown has called on oil industry leaders to come up with i...

Read More Comment Speech Bubble Have Your Say(0)

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year