GORDON Brown is facing his Dirty Harry moment. Like an outlaw hunted by Clint Eastwood’s movie cop Harry Callahan, the Prime Minister is confronted with a potentially fatal choice.
Either he can surrender and come along quietly, or he can “make our day” by provoking a final shoot-out that he cannot possibly win.
And it is the issue of fuel duty that marks the territory for Mr Brown’s last stand in his fight for political survival.
Virtually every household in Britain is feeling the squeeze from rocketing petrol and diesel prices, grossly inflated by the Treasury’s duty haul.
Yesterday the Daily Express took the crusade for a cut in fuel duty to Mr Brown’s doorstep. More than 100,000 readers have backed this newspaper’s call for an urgent and substantial reduction in duty on petrol and diesel.
As furious hauliers gridlocked central London in a mass protest over fuel duty and the summer air was filled with the sound of their lorry hooters, we handed over our petition to 10 Downing Street by the sackload. Every single crusade coupon in those bulging postbags is an eloquent argument for swift action over fuel prices.
The oil price surge means duty could be cut by 12p
The Prime Minister cannot pretend that he hasn’t heard the voice of Middle Britain; now he must decide how to respond.
Perhaps bitter experience might inform his choice. After all, he has been here once before. Just over two years ago, the Daily Express delivered a similar mass petition to Downing Street in protest at his cynical manipulation of inheritance tax to swell Treasury coffers at Middle Britain’s expense.
In his then position as Chancellor, Mr Brown ignored those demands. His decision turned out to be politically catastrophic. While some Treasury officials and even Cabinet ministers were discreetly pressing for a reduction in death duty stealth taxation, Mr Brown sneered.
Just look what happened. In a move that transformed the political landscape virtually overnight, the Tories pledged a massive cut in inheritance tax. That announcement produced a seismic opinion poll swing and ended Mr Brown’s honeymoon period as Prime Minister.
Chancellor Alistair Darling tried to mend the damage by unveiling Labour’s own, rather limp, inheritance tax reduction. But it was too late and the Government failed to gain a shred of the credit.
How Mr Brown must rue his failure to listen to Daily Express readers back then. Yet now the Prime Minister finds himself in a similar position.
It is an open secret at Westminster that scrapping the proposed 2p-a-litre rise in duty on petrol and diesel scheduled for October has been pencilled in to early drafts of Mr Darling’s autumn Pre-Budget Report.
David Cameron has dropped a big hint that the Tories are plotting an overhaul of the way fuel tax is calculated to reduce duty when crude oil prices rocket. Many officials and ministers are pressing Mr Darling for more rapid, and preferably far more radical, action.
Cabinet ministers are in revolt, terrified that Mr Brown is again dithering away an opportunity to ease the Government’s deep unpopularity. Perhaps he will see sense and seize a chance of salvaging something from his tattered reputation for financial competence. But the signs do not augur well.
Questioned about fuel duty in the Commons yesterday, the Prime Minister inexplicably began pleading poverty on the Treasury’s behalf. He dismissed suggestions of revenue windfall resulting from the oil price surge, claiming VAT and income tax receipts were dropping.
“Revenues are not up, revenues are down,” whined the architect of a decade of unrestrained taxing and spending. Yet the Treasury is raking in a £6billion windfall from the oil price surge, enough to cut fuel duty by at least 12p a litre.
Suddenly, after years of spending on ludicrous Labour vanity projects, voters are expected to believe that Mr Brown cannot find the cash to help desperately over-stretched families. Indeed, his pathetic claims of penury encapsulate the tragic position in which he finds himself.
His assumption of power in Number 10 coincided with the moment the gaff was blown on his stealth tax trickery.
While the economy expanded, house prices soared and incomes crept up, taxpayers were able to bear his sneaky increases in fuel taxes, stamp duty and other covert methods of pilfering our money.
Now times are tougher and household spending power is shrinking, any attempts to increase stealth taxation are instantly exposed and met with fierce resistance.
Ministers initially pretended only gas-guzzlers would be penalised by the latest raid on vehicle excise duty. Yesterday, Mr Brown was left pleading for mercy from his jittery backbenchers to avert yet another Commons rebellion and force the tax disc changes through.
The Government’s weakness in the face of a national revolt over taxation has been made all too clear. The Treasury has been forced into a series of retreats, over capital gains tax, levies on foreign tycoons and the abolition of the 10p starting rate for income tax.
On each issue, taxpayers made it clear that any further hikes in Labour’s crippling tax burden would not be tolerated. In the face of their rage, the Government backed down.
It means the stakes over fuel duty could hardly be higher. Petrol and diesel prices affect every household, both at the pumps and through increased transport costs for food and other essentials reflected in higher prices in the shops.
Last night the Daily Express petition voiced that discontent to Number 10. This morning Mr Brown (the most unpopular Prime Minister in our history) must decide if he can afford to take on that popular revolt.
In the words of Dirty Harry, he has to ask himself one question: “Do I feel lucky?”
IF YOU DON'T LISTEN TO US THIS TIME MR BROWN, YOU'RE GOING DOWN
04.07.08, 1:48pm
Taxes ! there are other factors in this matter, or indeed "these matters". What of "Mamon" or are they one and the same ?
Banish Super Markets. Expand the rail net work, not into grandiose supermega 1,000 mph jobs ! Perhaps narrow gauge to suit.
A network as Orange or Vodaphone.
Restore local communities, 'small' shops, Dr's, dentists, butcher, baker, candlestick maker,
"Feet On The Street, Stop and speak" Get to know people in you're neighbourhood. Hoodies have parents unlike "Topsy" ! Build confidence, trust. Do not remain disconnected from 'allies' in your solitary journey. This country appears to be under seige.
A street militia, armed with wisdom, "the ammunition of knowledge." Allow the Police to catch, oooops 'punish' litter louts, allow them to catch / punish the motorist, jail the elderly with unpaid community tax, the TV licence dodger. They 'may' do the admin, militia will deal with the pending, and emergency, trays ! Where the Generals' stand is unclear. The parliamentarians made thier position/practices known maybe, 400-500yrs past. Honest "Big business" will ride the waves.......Enjoy.
IF YOU DON'T LISTEN TO US THIS TIME MR BROWN, YOU'RE GOING DOWN
04.07.08, 1:48pm
Taxes ! there are other factors in this matter, or indeed "these matters". What of "Mamon" or are they one and the same ?
Banish Super Markets. Expand the rail net work, not into grandiose supermega 1,000 mph jobs ! Perhaps narrow gauge to suit.
A network as Orange or Vodaphone.
Restore local communities, 'small' shops, Dr's, dentists, butcher, baker, candlestick maker,
"Feet On The Street, Stop and speak" Get to know people in you're neighbourhood. Hoodies have parents unlike "Topsy" ! Build confidence, trust. Do not remain disconnected from 'allies' in your solitary journey. This country appears to be under seige.
A street militia, armed with wisdom, "the ammunition of knowledge." Allow the Police to catch, oooops 'punish' litter louts, allow them to catch / punish the motorist, jail the elderly with unpaid community tax, the TV licence dodger. They 'may' do the admin, militia will deal with the pending, and emergency, trays ! Where the Generals' stand is unclear. The parliamentarians made thier position/practices known maybe, 400-500yrs past. Honest "Big business" will ride the waves.......Enjoy.
Posted by: juan01 Report Comment
To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...