|
Columnists
![]()
|
UK NEWSBANNATYNE’S FEARS FOR SCOTLANDSunday February 1,2009 By Ben BorlandONE of Scotland’s leading millionaire businessmen has delivered a blow to Alex Salmond’s independence dream by warning many companies would fold during a split from the UK. Dragon’s Den tycoon Duncan Bannatyne insisted small businesses would be ten times worse off and said he believes Scotland must remain part of the Union to beat the recession. [>
The Coatbridge-born entrepreneur – who says he regards himself as British first and Scottish second – is worth an estimated £310million and runs the UK’s largest chain of health clubs from his base in the north-east of England. [>
Joining the Sunday Express Scotland’s Future debate on independence, he said yesterday: “I’m British. I’ve got six children born in England and we are British. [>
“We all need to work together and work harder to get out of the recession. [>
“For somebody to draw a line and say the Scottish, Welsh and English would do better on this side of the line is not going to help. [>
“I don’t believe we should separate, there is no benefit in it and there would be a huge cost to it. We will all suffer. [>
[> “For example, I don’t know how the Royal Bank of Scotland would have survived if it hadn’t been supported by the British Government. [>
“We can still have great pride in Scotland, but it is ten times better to be part of Great Britain.” [>
Bannatyne, who turns 60 tomorrow, also revealed his Dragon’s Den investments are thriving despite the downturn. Despite some deals falling through, he still retains a stake in six firms – Autosafe seatbelts, Razzamatazz stage schools, Blindsinabox, Chocbox, Igloo frozen foods and Pro Waste Management Services. [>
“The recession has had no real effect on most of them,” he said. [>
“It is definitely not affecting stage schools. Chocbox does business internationally so it has been affected [by the falling pound] and Blindsinabox sells to builders and housing developers, but the company is very well formed. It has money in the bank and is ready and willing to deal with any financial situation. [>
“Most small businesses are the same. I speak to business people every day and when I ask if they have been affected by the recession, apart from builders, estate agents and bankers, most say they haven’t been affected – yet.” [>
On Thursday, First Minister Alex Salmond admitted that Scotland is already in recession – although the official confirmation is not due for another three months. [>
The admission followed news that the downturn north of the Border is worse than elsewhere in the UK, which in turn was forecast to suffer the worst recession in the developed world. [>
However, Mr Salmond insisted that Scotland is still on track to meet the SNP’s economic targets and said: “It should be remembered that Scottish employment is higher than that of the UK average, Scottish unemployment is lower.” [>
However, the fresh comments against independence from one of the country’s most successful businessmen may come back to haunt the Nationalists before November next year. Bannatyne’s words are supported by Labour peer and MSP George Foulkes, who has written a special article for the Scotland’s Future debate in today’s Scottish Sunday Express. [>
The staunch Unionist said: “As we face the greatest global financial crisis for decades, Scots more than any others, realise a small country would be struggling to survive. [>
“The money to bail out RBS alone would have used up the total Scottish budget for a whole year.” [>
Last week, Sir Sean Connery launched the Scotland’s Future debate by urging politicians not to block the Referendum Bill and “to let the people speak”. [>
He said that an independent Scotland would have the “real financial teeth” necessary to deal with the global recession. [>
“In these tough economic times right across the world, independence for Scotland has never been more necessary,” he added. [>
|
|
|||||||||||||













FEAR FOR SCOTLAND
02.02.09, 8:49pm
Having spent some time thinking about Bannatyne's comments of an independant Scotland, I would say that Scotland would lose a huge amount of funding from Westminster that the government would need to provide for somehow. The only real source being increased taxes on the people and business. They could use the well worn out income ruse of oil taxes, but that idea is foolish at best.
Were I a business owner, facing greatly increased taxes, I would be likely to re-locate to a more favourable tax environment for my business-not Scotland! Were I living in Scotland with greatly increased taxes, I would move to a country with better taxes-not Scotland!
We are British people living in Wales, Northern Ireland, England and Scotland, with many unique traits for each country which is a strength of Britain. If you cut one piece off, all are negatively impacted.
Better to improve the quality of products made in Scotland/Britain, bring back manufacturing sold off to the Chinese , Indians, and others and build quality products that people want and need, and work an honest day for a decent wage instead of being held hostage by irrelevent unions that along with inept management and ownership has cripled the country for too long,and has caused irrepairable damage to Britain's reputation worldwide.
Posted by: IanBlacker Report Comment
BANNATYNE’S FEARS FOR SCOTLAND
02.02.09, 11:02am
I agree with Bannatyne. He is a successful business man and sure, that doesn't mean that he could run a country.
What have the SNP got apart from a romantic dream?
I think that the Scottish parliament up to date is a disaster and should be dismantled.
I shudder to think of a SNP led independent Scotland.
We all as the UK should be now focusing on the EU as this is most dangerous corrupt collection of rogues who are subdugating us drip by drip.
The SNP also agree with this.
Posted by: bigduke Report Comment
CARTOGRAPHY DOESN'T PAY THE MORTGAGE
01.02.09, 3:25pm
Scottish recession is steepest in UK … and UK recession is worst in world - Scotsman 29 January 2009
So we should stay in a political straitjacket that seees our economy go down quickest within the states who will suffer the worst recession.
Can someone explain to me how that is something we should stay with?
As they say: Those who do not learn from history are dommed to repeat it.
And erm what map? I don't see Scotland on any world map. Just the UK. Cartography doesn't pay the mortgage anyway if being put on a sheet of paper is the greatest ambition of some.
Posted by: BillieHeart Report Comment
BANNATYNE IS RIGHT
01.02.09, 3:07pm
It is significant that all of the pevious contributers live in areas where they have been hit between the eyes by flying haggis and ended up head first in a peat bog.
The Union helped to put Scoland on the map and it will be a sorry day when MacSalmond gets his independace which will drag us down to the status of Iceland.
Posted by: G0LDENARR0W Report Comment
MEANWHILE IN THE UK...
01.02.09, 1:11pm
"...warning many companies would fold during a split from the UK..."
Whilst at this moment in the UK, erm, many comoanies are, er folding.
So Mr Bannatyne's vision for Scotland is folding companies or, er, folding companies.
Sign me out of being "British" then. Whatever that means.
It's a pretty exclusivist thing if it's simply based on sending 59 bums to polish seats in Westminster. Also a bit arrogant considering there are plenty Canadians, Australians etc who see themselves as British.
Posted by: Norman_Conk Report Comment
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS
01.02.09, 11:55am
"Chocbox does business internationally "
How can it do that without being in the UK? Undermines his argument.
As do recent developments. It can't be a good advert for British companies internationally when they are watching news items showing it connected with calls for protectionism.
Posted by: FreakinDoo Report Comment
To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...